• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to MJ Stevens

MJ Stevens, a veteran-owned American restaurant in Hartford, WI, offers a unique blend of Wisconsin Supper Club and upscale Steakhouse vibes. With a diverse menu featuring seafood, steaks, pastas, and their specialty prime rib, diners can expect generous portions and flavorful dishes. The warm and inviting atmosphere, attentive service, and extensive drink options contribute to a memorable dining experience. Despite being somewhat remote, the quality of food and service make it worth the trip. From their outstanding Cod Oscar to melt-in-your-mouth BBQ ribs, MJ Stevens promises a satisfying culinary journey for all who visit.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to MJ Stevens, a veteran-owned gem nestled at 5260 Aurora Rd in Hartford, WI. This American restaurant offers a unique blend of American, Desserts, and Seafood cuisines, making it a versatile dining spot for all tastes.

From taking reservations to offering delivery and catering services, MJ Stevens goes above and beyond to cater to their customers' needs. With amenities like outdoor seating, wheelchair accessibility, and free Wi-Fi, this restaurant ensures a comfortable dining experience for all.

But what truly sets MJ Stevens apart is its exceptional menu offerings. Customers rave about dishes like the Cod Oscar and the succulent prime rib, cooked to perfection. The extensive menu includes appetizers, salads, sandwiches, pastas, seafood, and steaks, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.

Customers also praise the warm and inviting ambiance of MJ Stevens, which combines the charm of a Wisconsin Supper Club with the sophistication of a first-rate Steakhouse. The attentive service provided by experienced staff members adds to the overall dining experience.

So, if you find yourself traveling between Milwaukee and Fond du Lac, make sure to stop by MJ Stevens for a memorable dining experience. While the prices may be on the higher side, the quality of food and service make it a worthwhile visit. Whether you're craving a delicious lunch, dinner, or Saturday/Sunday Brunch, MJ Stevens promises to leave you satisfied and coming back for more.

START YOUR REVIEW OF MJ Stevens
Katie D.
Katie D.

Just stopped in on our way between Chicago and Stevens Point. We had a nice lunch and great service. Happy to find MJ Stevens during our travels.

John H.
John H.

Cod Oscar is outstanding and a great option to the normal menotinous Friday fish fry.

Vicky B.
Vicky B.

Located at almost its own exit off of Highway 41 between Milwaukee and Fond du Lac - sitting pretty much alone in the middle of not much else, you'll find the throwback to a simpler time in the form of a uniquely decorated, warm and inviting hybrid of a Wisconsin Supper Club and a first rate Steakhouse's called MJ Stevens. The entrance leads directly into the huge yet cozy bar with the big u-shaped actual bar that may be required for a bonafide supper club. And the definite requisite awesome old fashioned (the drink). My friend had one and said it was delicious. The kids (ages 16-18) went for the kiddie cocktails - because where else can they get them? A decent wine and beer list was also sampled. The only deviation from the supper clubs of my past was no relish tray on the lazy Susan - I missed it. The menu is huge - appetizers, salads, sandwiches, pastas, seafood, steaks, full dinners that included chicken a la Oscar, seafood moray and cordon bleu. Their specialty is prime Rib with several sizes and preparations. The steaks are also amazing and served with au jus and homemade horseradish cream. Meals all come with choice of a nice house salad with amazing homemade dressings, or a choice from two homemade soups - when we were there it was cream of duck or roasted red pepper with shrimp! In addition they serve warm, freshly baked bread and choice of potato. Friends had prime rib (huge and delicious cooked perfectly), 8 oz filet mignon (same as prime rib -perfect), a couple of pastas recommended by our server and huge portions there too. I had a half rack of the bbq ribs - the size was more like a full rack - I ate 3 ribs and took home I think 6 or 7 more. These ribs were amazingly tender - the bones just slid away from the meat without any utensils or prodding from me. It was melt in your mouth delicious with a tangy mild sauce that complimented the meat without overwhelming. The service was absolutely wonderful. Our server was not a teenager and has probably been there at least 20 years. She was well-versed on every menu item and made great recommendations after asking a couple of questions to determine likes/dislikes. No room for dessert but they had a ton of yummy choices. If you ever find yourself between Fond du Lac and Milwaukee, treat yourself to a wonderful lunch, dinner or Saturday/Sunday Brunch - you'll be very glad you did. The absent 5th star is for three reasons: location is remote, the ambiance can be pretty loud, and the prices are on the high side. But I'll go back at every chance I get up that way - definitely worth the drive!

Rick S.
Rick S.

Just an update with photos of the inside of the restaurant and of their wonderful fish fry. Our server last night was Sandy and she has been there many years. She's fabulous!